Most people treat a year as a fact you either know or not. Know your history and you score; skip it and you guess. The guesses say something else: they are not scattered around the real date, they lean one way. That matters for which game you pick, because some give you a photo full of clues and some give you one line and a ribbon.
Old dates slide toward today, and they slide one way
When roughly looked at the Bronze Age guesses in When?, the pattern held for every object.
in 100 guesses landed closer to today than the real date
Typical Bronze Age object, 4,301 guesses on 15 objects older than 1000 BC.
Quelle: roughly blog, Bronze Age guessesThat means the miss is not noise. Not one of the 15 typical guesses landed earlier than the real date. The first palace at Knossos went up around 1900 BC; players typically put it in 309 BC. Researchers have a name for the same pull on far longer scales. Kefyn Catley and Laura Novick asked students to date events in Earth's history and found they were "generally estimated to have occurred more recently than they actually did". They called it forward telescoping.
A photo gives you clues, a ribbon gives you none
The slide is strongest where the clues run out, and that is where the games differ most.
| Game | What you see | What you answer |
|---|---|---|
| TimeGuessr | a historic photo | where and when it was taken |
| Chronophoto | a photo from 1900 to today | the year |
| When? | one thing, a pictogram and a line | the year only, on a ribbon from 3000 BC to today |
That is why the photo games and When? suit different moods. A photo has clothes, cars and colour to read, and Chronophoto keeps to the years since 1900, where the same post found the pull reversed: things from after 1900 were dated a few years too early. When? gives you no picture of the past at all and a line 5,000 years long. That is where forward telescoping bites hardest, and where a reveal teaches you the most.
Part of the slide is the timeline, not all of it
The fair objection: the game's own line could cause this. On When?, 3000 to 1000 BC fills 7 percent of the ribbon, and guesses drift away from both ends. That pushes the oldest objects inward.
It explains part of the miss. It cannot explain two objects from the same century and the same spot on the line. The Sphinx and Mohenjo-daro were both built around 2500 BC. Players put the Sphinx at 1653 BC and Mohenjo-daro at AD 754, about 2,400 years apart. The post's reading: what people picture well stays put, and what they cannot picture gets filed with the Greeks and Romans, or later.
For the twentieth century, the slide almost disappears
If your favourite rounds are photos from the last hundred years, this post is not your problem. The pull shows up for the deep past, not for the decade a car was built.
For everything older, use one anchor pair. Cleopatra lived closer in time to the Moon landing than to the building of the Great Pyramid. Place the pyramid first, then Rome, then your object, and push it further back than feels right. The same one-way miss shows up in sizes too: players make the Hindenburg five times too small. For more dailies with a number as the answer, the games like Wordle but not words list and the Amountle post are the next stops.
Five moments a day, placed on one line from 3000 BC to today.
Play today's When?Sources 6
- TimeGuessr - guess where and when historic photos were taken, daily challenge
- Chronophoto - guess the year a photo was taken, from 1900 to today, with a daily mode
- When was the Bronze Age? Players put it 1,500 years too late - the When? guesses, the Sphinx and Mohenjo-daro, the timeline objection
- Catley and Novick, essay on their 2009 study - students date deep-time events too recently
- WorldAtlas, Cleopatra and the Moon landing - pyramid, Cleopatra and Apollo 11 dates compared
- When? on roughly - the ribbon from 3000 BC to today, how a round is scored